PREMIUM LEGAL RESOURCES
ASK A LAWYER
WHAT IS A CRIMINAL CASE?
Criminal cases range from relatively minor offenses such as traffic
infractions to serious ones like robbery and murder. The state makes the
charge against someone accused of committing a crime because a crime is
considered an act against society. The prosecuting attorney presents
the charge against the accused person (defendant) on behalf of the state
(plaintiff), and must prove to the judge or jury that the defendant is
guilty. In all criminal cases, the defendant is presumed to be
innocent, and may not be convicted, unless proved guilty beyond a
A criminal case begins when a prosecutor files formal charges, a person
is arrested, or a grand jury issues an indictment.
If a defendant--the person accused of a crime--is in custody, he or she
has the right to an arraignment, usually held in a municipal or justice
court, within 48 hours of being arrested. At the hearing, the judge will
officially tell defendants about their constitutional rights and explain
the charges against them. Also, bail may be raised or lowered and
defendants may request to be released on their promise to appear OR (on
their own recognizance).
If a defendant who has been charged with a felony or a misdemeanor
cannot afford to hire an attorney, the court will appoint one from the
public defender's office. (Since infraction convictions do not result in
jail or prison terms, the court does not appoint a public defender in
Defendants also will be asked to plead to the charges against them:
guilty, not guilty, or, in some cases, nolo contendere (the person does
not contest the charges, which legally is the same as a guilty plea).
Defendants who plead guilty to a misdemeanor may be sentenced during the
first arraignment, unless the judge wishes to postpone sentencing in
order to study a probation report.
During the arraignment, if a defendant pleads not guilty to a
misdemeanor, the judge will set the date for a trial in the municipal or
justice court within 30 days if the defendant is in custody or within 45
days if the defendant is not in custody--unless the defendant waives the
right to a speedy trial.
If a defendant pleads guilty to a felony at this first appearance, he or
she must be represented by an attorney (unless the defendant, in a
noncapital case, waives the right to one). After a guilty plea in
municipal or justice court, the judge has the option to keep the case in
that court for sentencing or probation or to transfer the case to a
If a defendant pleads not guilty to a felony, a preliminary hearing is
held in the municipal or justice court, where the district attorney must
show evidence that the defendant committed a felony and should be
brought to trial. This step (or the alternative--a grand jury
indictment) is necessary to make sure that only defendants against whom
there is significant evidence are compelled to undergo a felony trial.
If the judge decides that the district attorney did not show enough
evidence, the charges will be dropped and the defendant will go free.
However, if the judge decides there is enough evidence, the defendant
will be arraigned a second time in superior court, where the defendant
again will be formally charged, rights will be explained, and a plea
will be made.
Both felony and misdemeanor cases go to trial only rarely. Most (over 90
percent) are disposed of by defendants' pleas of guilty. Of all the
cases that do go to jury trial, the majority are related to DUI offenses
(driving under the influence). Whether the case involves a felony or
misdemeanor, the trial follows the same pattern.
If the case goes to trial in superior court, the district attorney, on
behalf of the State of California, first files an information (a written
charge against a defendant filed in superior court after a preliminary
examination in a municipal or justice court) or an indictment (a written
accusation presented upon oath by a grand jury that a person has
committed a crime).
Not guilty plea: When a defendant enters a plea of not guilty, the case
proceeds to trial. The jury is selected--12 people plus alternate jurors
if the trial is expected to be long. At the trial, lawyers on each side
of the case may make brief statements (called opening statements) to the
jury outlining what they expect to prove with the evidence they have.
Presentation of evidence: Each side then has a turn to present evidence,
which can be pictures, objects, documents, or sworn testimony by
witnesses. Evidence must have a direct tendency to prove or disprove the
issues in the case. There are evidence rules that are intended to ensure
that unreliable evidence is not received.
Objections: During a trial, if attorneys on either side feel that a
question asked or evidence offered is improper, they may make
objections. The judge may sustain or overrule such objections.
Closing arguments: After both sides have presented their evidence, each
has a chance to present rebuttal evidence. Then both sides of the case
give their closing arguments. This is the stage when the attorneys
analyze and interpret the evidence that was presented.
Verdict: The judge will instruct the jury on the law that applies to the
case. The jury then moves to the jury room to reach a verdict.
If it reaches a guilty verdict in a felony case, the judge will order a
probation report and schedule a sentencing hearing for 20 days later.
A misdemeanor can be sentenced immediately.
Sentences: State and local laws define crimes and specify punishment.
The maximum sentence for an infraction is a fine; for a misdemeanor it
is up to one year in a county jail; and for a felony it is time in a
state prison or, for some murders, death. Some counties offer
"diversion" programs that allow a judge to order a defendant to get
medical treatment or counseling or to do community service work. The
diversion program may take the place of a fine or jail sentence in
certain types of misdemeanor and felony charges.
[Note: The laws and procedures referred are subject to change.]
Brought to you by - The 'Lectric Law Library
The Net's Finest Legal Resource For Legal Pros & Laypeople Alike.