PREMIUM LEGAL RESOURCES
ASK A LAWYER
From: [email protected] (Rich Winkel)
Subject: Using the Freedom of Information Act
Date: 25 Nov 1992
>From INSIGHT FEATURES / CONTENTS / November 1992
If any IF articles are downloaded for use in the print media,
please call us. Our rates are cheap or, in many cases, there is no
cost at all. There is no fee for downloads to other BBS or for your
private reading, but please send us your comments anyway. Call VOICE
312/384-8827 or leave E-MAIL with PEACENET's NFD.GEN Conference or
for Insight Features at NY ON-LINE.
Using the Freedom of Information Act
How To Get Information from the Government
By Mary O'Connell and Patti Wolter
The Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) guarantees citizens access to
information about what the government and its various bureaucracies
are doing. Congress passed the federal Freedom of Information Act in
1966. Since then, state laws have expanded on the federal
guarantees. The Illinois was effective July 1, 1984.
What it means is that any citizen has the right to follow up on the
records of the institutions governing society--such as property title
and deed transfers, court cases and politician's voting records.
FOIA requests can lead to public disclosure of information useful to
organizers--such as environmental impact studies or budget
allocations to certain projects. In one Utah case, FOIA requests
proved government knowledge of health hazards (including cancer risk)
caused by atomic fallout from testing in Nevada. In another
instance, National Highway Safety Administration documents disclosed
to the public forced the recall of 500 defective tires.
While federal FOI laws do not apply to state or local governments,
most states have their own open records laws--some of which are more
inclusive than the federal law. Any documents of a state or local
agency which are submitted to a federal agency, however,
automatically become subject to the federal FOIA. Contact your state
attorney general's office for copies of your state's act.
What Can You Get?
The federal law covers all agencies of the federal government, from
the Pentagon to your local post office. It does not extend to
activities at the White house, Congress, the federal courts or
private corporations. The Illinois law covers all branches of the
state and local government except the judiciary. It also applies to
all local public bodies, including school districts, city and county
governments, state universities, and the innumerable board, bureaus
and committees that spend tax dollars. Local bodies may have their
own FOI regulations.
In general, you're entitled to review and copy public records of any
of these bodies. These can include reports, forms, memoranda, maps,
photographs, microfilms, tapes and computerized data. You can be
charged for the cost of searching for and copying the records;
however, if you can prove disclosure of the information will benefit
the public, those fees may be waived. This provision usually applies
to journalists, researchers and scholars.
What Can't You Get
The law assumes you are entitled to information unless specified
otherwise. Exemptions are for such information as:
--classified material (federal);
--information that would invade personal privacy, such as medical
records, personnel files, student records (although other laws
guarantee you access to your own files);
--trade secrets, sealed bids, exam questions and answers--the kind of
information that would give you unfair advantage over others;
--investigatory records which, if released, would "impede law
enforcement, disclose confidential sources or investigative
--documents concerning government regulation or supervision of
--internal agency memoranda and policy discussions;
--oil and gas wells (location of and other trade specifications).
How Does It Work?
Formal written requests for information (as opposed to inquiries in
person or over the phone) are the only requests considered as falling
within the FOI guidelines and subject to the law.
Mention in your letter that you are asking for information under the
FOIA. Identify the source that led you to this agency. (For example,
send a clipping that mentions the study you want, or give the name of
the person who referred you.) Describe what you want as specifically
as possible (documents, letters, bills, financial records relating to
the sale of the former school building at 1211 Oak St.). You are not
required to explain why you are making the request.
Mention that you will expect a reply within seven days (10 days for
the federal government). If you want copies of records--not just the
chance to look at them--you can specify how much you are willing to
pay for copying, in case your request turns out to be bigger than you
expected. Keep a copy of all correspondence.
Once you submit your written request, the government must reply
within seven (or 10) working days. They can give you the
information, ask for an extension, or turn you down.
Extensions cover situations where the records are stored elsewhere,
where they require an extensive search, where the agency wants time
to review them for exempt material or to check with another agency
involved in the case, or where the seven-day limit is "unduly
burdensome." Extensions cover the same period as the original
Be persistent. Despite deadline requirements for releasing
information, in practice some agencies will take months (or even
years) to fulfill an FOI request. At the same time, if you can prove
you need a document urgently--for example, for a court case-- you can
also persuade the agency to meet your request early.
Getting What You Want
The more targeted your request for information, the more likely you
are to get the specific information you need. This means filing your
request with the appropriate agency of office as well as knowing what
kinds of documents you're looking for (as opposed to asking for
general information on a subject). Most large agencies have a
designated FOI officer to handle requests; if no such officer exists,
it is a good idea to call and find out how to best direct your
Federal law requires each agency to issue quarterly indexes of its
records dating back to July 4, 1967. Illinois law requires each
public body to make available "reasonably detailed" lists of its
records and information on how they are stored. The information must
be comprehensible even to those who don't understand computers.
You can also call an agency and ask about records on your subject,
trying to first identify what will be most useful to you. Also, if
the information you need is not stored elsewhere, sometimes visiting
the office and viewing the documents there, rather than than waiting
for copies to arrive in the mail, is quicker.
What If They Say No?
Under provisions of the FOIA, once you make a written request for
information, the burden of compliance with the law is on the agency.
If the agency denies your request (not answering within a time limit
is a denial), they have to say why that information is exempt. If
only a part of what they ask for is exempt, they have to cut that
part out and send you the rest.
The first step in appealing a denial is to write a formal letter
citing the date and basic information of your original request, the
date of the denial, and a statement that you believe the denial
violated the FOIA. Send the letter and copies of all previous
correspondence to the head of the agency (state or local) or to
specified federal appeals offices.
If you get no action in 20 days of your request or appeal, you can
file a lawsuit provided you have the appropriate copies of the paper
trail). If you win, you can still be awarded attorneys' fees if the
material is considered of significant public interest.
For a 32-page booklet, How To Use The Freedom of Information Act,
contact the FOI Service Center, c/o Reporters Committee, 1735 Eye St,
NW, Suite 504, Washington DC 20006, 202-466-6312. The book contains
an actual copy of the act. It also summarizes and explains how to
use the act; list Supreme Court cases which are relevant to the act
(and their rulings); contains a directory of addresses for federal
agencies; and gives sample letters for requests, appeals, a filing a
lawsuit. Cost is $3.
Mary O'Connell and Patti Wolter edit The Neighborhood Works, the
newsletter of the Center for Neighborhood Technology, 2125 W North
Ave, Chicago, IL 60647. 312-248-4800.
Brought to you by - The 'Lectric Law Library
The Net's Finest Legal Resource For Legal Pros & Laypeople Alike.