Date: June 14, 1995
The Attorney General of California has prepared the following title and
summary of the chief purpose and points of the proposed measure:
ATTORNEYS' CONTINGENT FEES LIMITS INITIATIVE STATUTE.
Limits fees which plaintiffs' attorneys may collect, if payable
contingent on plaintiffs' recovery of compensation, in personal injury,
wrongful death, other tort cases. Hourly rates not limited. Requires
demand against defendants for compensation with supporting information.
Allows defendants to respond with early settlement offer with supporting
information. If accepted, plaintiffs' attorneys may not collect
contingent fees exceeding 15% of defendants' offer. If not accepted,
they may collect fees above 15% only on part of recovery in excess of
defendants' early settlement offer. Fiduciary relationship applies to
fee agreement between plaintiff, plaintiff's attorney. Summary of
estimate by Legislative Analyst and Director of Finance of fiscal impact
on state and local governments: The fiscal impact of this measure on
state and local governments is unknown. It could result in either net
savings or costs, depending largely on how attorneys and their clients
respond to contingency limits.
Lawyer Contingent Fee Limitation Act
SECTION ONE. This Act shall be known and may be cited as the "Lawyer
Contingent Fee Limitation Act".
SECTION TWO. The People of the State of California find and declare:
(a) The contingent-fee arrangements lawyers typically negotiate with
claimants, most of whom are inexperienced and unsophisticated purchasers
of legal services, often require claimants to pay their lawyers too much
for handling tort claims that a defendant has offered to settle.
(b) These excessive fees harm claimants by depriving them of
compensation they deserve.
(c) The excessive fees also discourage early settlement of tort claims,
forcing injured people to suffer long delays in receiving compensation
and clogging the courts with lawsuits that should not have to be filed.
(d) Imposing a cap on the fees lawyers can charge for handling tort
claims that a defendant has offered to settle quickly would:
(1) Prevent lawyers from taking an unreasonable portion of the
compensation offered or awarded to an injured person.
(2) Encourage defendants to settle claims quickly.
(3) Enable injured people to be compensated more promptly.
(4) Relieve some of the present burden placed on the courts, reducing
costs for taxpayers and enabling other legal disputes to be resolved
SECTION THREE. Sections 6146.1, 6146.2, 6146.3, 6146.4, 6146.5 and
6146.6 of Article 8.5 of Chapter 4 of Division 3 of the Business and
Professions Code are added as follows:
6146.1 [CONTINGENT-FEE LIMITATIONS] (a) An attorney who represents a
claimant who has accepted an early settlement offer shall not collect a
contingent fee that is greater than 15% of the amount of the early
(b) An attorney who represents a claimant who has rejected or failed to
accept an early settlement offer shall not collect a contingent fee that
is greater than 15% of the amount of the early settlement offer plus
such percentage of the amount recovered in excess of the early
settlement offer as was agreed to by the claimant and the attorney.
(c) A claimant's attorney who has failed to make a demand for
compensation pursuant to Section 6146.2, or who has omitted from such
demand information required under Section 6146.2 of a material nature
which the attorney had in his or her possession or which was readily
available to him or her, shall not collect a contingent fee greater than
15% of the amount recovered.
(d) A claimant's attorney who has failed to provide his or her client a
true and complete copy of an early settlement offer received by the
attorney, as required under subdivision (c) of Section 6146.3, shall not
collect a contingent fee greater than 15% of the amount recovered.
(e) Reasonable costs and expenses incurred by an attorney up to the time
of receipt of an early settlement offer shall be deducted from that
settlement offer for purposes of calculating the maximum permissible fee
under subdivisions (a) and (b).
(f) An attorney shall disclose, plainly and in writing, to claimants
whom the attorney proposes to represent on a contingent-fee basis, (1)
the fee limitations imposed by this section and (2) the fact that such
limitations are maximum limits and that the attorney and claimant may
negotiate a lower fee. The attorney shall also provide to each such
claimant a copy of this act.
(g) The fee limitations imposed by this section may not be waived.
(h) The provisions of this section apply to all attorneys practicing in
California, including attorneys prosecuting claims filed in federal
court, to the maximum extent permitted by federal law.
6146.2 [CLAIMANT'S DEMAND FOR COMPENSATION] (a) An attorney representing
a claimant on a contingent-fee basis shall send a demand for
compensation by certified mail to each allegedly responsible party. In
the event that multiple allegedly responsible parties are known to the
attorney, a demand shall be sent on the same date to each such party.
The demand shall specify the amount of compensation sought and shall set
forth the material facts, documentary evidence, and other information
relevant to the demand, including:
(1) The name and address of the claimant or of the person on whose
behalf the claim is being made.
(2) A brief description of how the injury or loss occurred.
(3) The names and, if known, the addresses and telephone numbers of all
known witnesses to the injury or loss.
(4) Copies of photographs in the claimant's possession which relate to
the injury or loss.
(5) The basis for claiming that the party to whom the demand is
addressed is responsible or partially responsible for the injury or
(6) A description of the nature of the injury or loss, including the
dates and nature of the care or services provided, and the names and
addresses of all physicians and other health-care providers that
provided medical care or services to the claimant or injured party.
(7) Medical records relating to the injury, including those involving a
prior injury or pre-existing medical condition which would be
discoverable by the allegedly responsible party during the course of
litigation or, in lieu thereof, executed releases authorizing the
allegedly responsible party to obtain such records directly from those
health-care providers who provided treatment to the claimant.
(8) Documentation of any medical expenses, lost wages, personal losses,
and other economic and non-economic losses suffered as a consequence of
the injury or loss.
(b) The attorney shall mail copies of each demand to the claimant and to
each and every allegedly responsible party.
(c) A claimant's attorney who learns of an additional allegedly
responsible party after making a demand for compensation under
subdivision (a) shall send a demand for compensation to the newly
discovered allegedly responsible party and simultaneously mail a copy of
such demand to each of the other allegedly responsible parties and to
(d) In the event that a claimant's attorney learns of an additional
allegedly responsible party more than 90 days after making a demand for
compnsation under subdivision (a), the attorney shall not be required to
send a demand to that party nor shall the fee limitations imposed under
subdivisions (a) and (b) of Section 6146.1 apply with regard to any
amount recovered from that party, excepted as next provided. An attorney
who fails as a result of a breach of the standard of care to learn of an
additional allegedly responsible party within 90 days of sending a
demand for compensation to another allegedly responsible party shall not
collect a fee in excess of that allowed under subdivisions (a) and (b)
of Section 6146.1 with respect to any amount recovered from such
additional allegedly responsible party.
6146.3 [EARLY SETTLEMENT OFFER] (a) An offer by an allegedly responsible
party to settle a claim shall constitute an early settlement offer if
the allegedly responsible party:
(1) makes the settlement offer within 60 days of receipt of a demand for
(2) communicates the offer in writing and by certified mail to the
(3) leaves the offer open for acceptance for a minimum of 30 days from
the date of its receipt by the claimant's attorney; and
(4) includes with the offer material information and documentary
evidence in its possession relating to the alleged injury or loss upon
which the allegedly responsible party relied in making the settlement
(A) Copies of photographs which relate to the injury or loss.
(B) The basis for claiming, if it is so claimed, that the allegedly
responsible party is not responsible, or is less responsible than is
alleged by the claimant, for the alleged injury or loss.
(C) Information regarding injuries or losses suffered by the claimant.
(b) An allegedly responsible party may amend or issue an additional
early settlement offer during the 60-day period set forth in subdivision
(a). An amended or additional early settlement offer shall be subject to
the requirements set forth in subdivision (a).
(c) A settlement offer that is made to a claimant prior to receipt of a
demand for compensation, and which conforms to the requirements of
subdivision (a), shall be deemed an early settlement offer and shall
have the same effect as if it were a response to a demand for
(d) An allegedly responsible party is under no obligation to issue a
response to a demand for compensation. The fact that a demand for
compensation was or was not made, the fact that an early settlement
offer was or was not made, and the amount of any demand or settlement
offer made are inadmissible pursuant to Section 1152 of the Evidence
(e) An attorney who receives an early settlement offer shall provide a
true and complete copy of such offer to his or her client.
6146.4 [ENFORCEMENT] A claimant who is charged a contingent fee that is
higher than that authorized under Section 6146.1, except as provided
under subdivision (d) of Section 6146.2, may maintain an action against
that attorney. Such claimant is entitled to recover from such attorney
three times the amount overcharged or $10,000, whichever is greater.
6146.5 [FIDUCIARY RELATIONSHIP] A fiduciary relationship applies with
respect to any fee agreement between an attorney and a claimant.
6146.6 [DEFINITIONS] For purposes of Section 6146.1 through 6146.5, the
following terms have the following meanings:
(1) "Allegedly responsible party" means a person, partnership, or
corporation alleged by a claimant to be responsible for at least some
portion of an injury or loss alleged by that claimant.
(2) "Amount recovered" means the total compensation, including the
reasonable value of non-monetary compensation, that an attorney has
obtained on behalf of a claimant through settlement, arbitration, or
judgment, minus the reasonable costs and expenses incurred by the
attorney in prosecuting or settling the claim.
(3) "Claimant" means any natural person or persons seeking compensation
in connection with a tort claim including, but not limited to, a claim
for personal injury or wrongfu death. However, a claimant does not
include any person or persons seeking compensation in connection with a
claim covered by Section 6146, a claim for workers' compensation
benefits, or a case in which a court has certified the existence of a
class action pursuant to state or federal law.
(4) "Contingent fee" means compensation, however calculated, that is
payable only if an amount is recovered. (5) "Early settlement offer"
means a settlement offer made in accordance with Section 6146.3.
SECTION FOUR. (a) Except as provided in subdivision (b) of this section,
the provisions of this initiative shall not be amended except by a
statute that becomes effective only when approved by the electorate.
(b) The provisions of this initiative may be amended only to further its
purposes, by a statute passed in each house of the Legislature by roll
call vote entered in the journal, two-thirds of the membership of each
house concurring. In any judicial action with respect to such amendment,
the court shall exercise its independent judgment and shall determine
whether the amendment is supported by findings clearly and convincingly
establishing that the amendment furthers the initiative's purposes.
SECTION FIVE. If any provision of this act or application thereof to any
person or circumstance is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect
other provisions or applications of the act which can be given effect
without the invalid provision or application, and to this end the
provisions of this act are severable.
Brought to you by - The 'Lectric Law Library
The Net's Finest Legal Resource For Legal Pros & Laypeople Alike.